GPD XD compared with nintendo N3DS

I brought a 64GB GPD XD In the GDP official Japanese amazon store http://www.amazon.co.jp/s?marketplaceID=A1VC38T7YXB528&redirect=true&me=A1FN6S0F7UF5K9&merchant=A1FN6S0F7UF5K9 Now let’s take it comparison with the nintendo N3DS

1.The different ARM.

N3DS adopted Quad-core ARM11 MPCore + Quad-core VFP Co-Processor.Base Frequency is only 268MHz.support ARMv5、ARMv6 Instruction set.GPU is PICA200 from DMP company. Base Frequency is only 200MHz.This GPU is early adopted in the age of 3DS LL, only support OpenGL ES 1.1. But until nintendo 3 ds, it is still in use.

GPD XD adopt Quad-core ARM Cortex-A17,Its named RK3288.Base Frequency is 1.8GHz.support ARMv7 Instruction set. GPU is Mali-T764 core.Base Frequency is 600MHz.This level can support OpenGL ES 3.0.

If we say the latter is the real sense of the processor.The former may just a toy for kids.

  1. The RAM is different.

N3DS adopted the 10MB VRAM(6MB+4MB),This level may can’t catch the TNT2 graphics card that I brought in 2002.RAM also just use a 256MB FCRAM.

While for XD adopted double architecture processor RK3288,GPU Shared memory.So, in theory XD RAM can be used as a Video Memory.The RAM is 2G DDR3,This capacity is 8 times of nintendo N3DS. Although FCRAM is power saving,but this technology is decade ago after all.And if XD just want to save electricity,they can use LPDDR3 completely, but in order to get a high performance,XD adopted DDR3. The speed is much more quickly than FCRAM.

3.The ROM is different. N3DS adopted 4 gb samsung NAND FLASH,This capacity are even less than the lowest smartphone now. XD adopted the 16GB/32GB/64GB samsung eMMC PRO.10 nm NAND flash memory technology.the read speed can up to 250MB/s.write speed can up to 90MB/s. The speed is almost same with SATA2 interface hard disk.And, XD support maximum 128 gb UHS - I interface Class 10 standard SDXC SD card, The total memory can achieve 192 GB.

4.The battery is different. N3DS adopted 1750mAH lithium battery.Analysised combine with the ultra low power processor and ultra-low power consumption FCRAM, it is not hard to find that nintendo N3DS is always used the electric salved components.So these are the reason why N3DS can just play the games don’t require high rendering like 《Super Smash Bros》or《monster handle》.Because of the lower machine performance.

While XD adopted the 6000mAh lithium battery.Actually, if we just in order to consider the power saving, XD can use LPDDR3 memory, but why use the DDR3, cause the original design of XD never consider the power saving.After all, the battery is enough to play any game for 8 hours.

5.The display is different. For the screen of N3DS I don’t want to say anything, “the naked eye 3D” screen, always give people a sense of surprise shock. In fact, if there is no 3D game to play, the screen is worthless.

XD adopted a 5 inch H-IPS screen.The resolution up to 1280 * 720.Someone may question this resolution seems lower than a phone screen. But, you know, too high resolution is often slow console performance, too low resolution screen will particles, so this resolution just Achieve the balance.

6.the gamespad is different. N3DS joystick and function keys do not need too much words, we all should know. Here I focus on the function keys of XD , XD is Adopted original 3D Joystick from Japanese ALPS with rotating life up to 5 million times. It is produced by the same company as PSV joystick but with upgraded material.in order to prevent slipping, added a rubber sleeve above the rocker. L1/L2/R1/R2 key using the Japanese OMRON micro switch, support more than 2 million times mechanical type, This kind of micro switch that only adopted by Microsoft, Logitech and other large brands. In addition, the XYAB key uses double character screen printing by 360 and Sony handle. In this way, you can easily identify the key in different games.

7.The supported games is different. N3DS only supports their own platform game. While the supported games of XD is too much.I just checked the application of Happy Chick from XD.It can support PSP、NDS、N64、PS、 ARCADE/FBA、GBA、SFC/SNES、MAME、MD/Genesis、WSC、FC/NES、GBC、DC、ONS、NGP、PCE、MAMEPlus emulator.and also support ARCADE、MAMEPlus、 PCE、PSP、DC、ONS、NGP、NDS、N64、PS、MAME、GBA、SFC、ANDROID、MD、FC、WSC、GBC emulator. Of course, more than that, the following are the emulaters that show good performance on XD written by a game palyer. PS/PSP FC/SFC/VB/N64 GB/GBC/GBA/NDS SMS/GG/MD/MDCD/MD32X/SS/DC PCE/PCECD/PCFX NGP/NGPC/WS/WSC/3DO Atari2600/7800/Lynx/Jaguar And The latest version of MAME2015/FBA and multi arcade host MESS2015. MAME already include the latest Cave3 and IGS games.For CHD games,it is also supported. The most important is through the HDMI connection TV, play the game simulator super cool, external to the maximum of 5 wireless handles, Allowing on-line group sports for 5 people

1.Host system Atari 2600 : Ataroid(Under shelf)RetroArch 2600.emu
Atari 5200:JXD-a5200 Atari 7800:JXD-a7800 Colecovision :ColEm Intellivision :jzintv4droid Vectrex:Android-Vectrex

FC/NES/FDS : nes.emu RetroArch SFC : Snes9x EX / Snes9x EX+ RetroArch N64 : N64oid Mupen64+AE VB:RetroArch NGC:Dolphin Wii:Dolphin

PCE(SG)/ PCE-CD : PCE.emu RetroArch

SG1000:RetroArch SMS :RetroArch Md.Emu MD : RetroArch Md.Emu MD 32X:RetroArch MDCD: Md.Emu RetroArch SS : Yabause AE Saturn.emu DC: reicast nullDCe

PS: FPSE epsxe RetroArch

2.Consoles system

Atari Lynx: RetroArch Pokémon-Mini:pokemini GB/GBC:GBC.emu RetroArch GBA:my boy! gba.emu RetroArch NDS: DraStic(charge) nds4droid

GG: RetroArch Gearoid(Under shelf) MasterGear
DC VMU :Visual Memory Emulator

NGP/NGPC : ngp.emu RetroArch WSC/WS :RetroArch

PSP : PPSSPP

3.Arcade system

MAME: RetroArch:MAME2014 Based on MAME0.151 MAME4Droid Reloaded Based on mame 0.139 RetroArch:MAME2003 Based on MAME 0.78 MAME4droid Based on mame 0.37b5

FBA: fba4droid tigerARC

4.PC system

Acron/BBC Micro :Beebdroid Atari 8 bit (800/400/xl/xe): colleen
Amiga 500 :UAE4Droid
Amstrad CPC:CPCDroid Apple 1 :POM1 Apple 2 :cAndy Apple Apple 2gs :KEGS Atari ST : SToid C64 :C64.emu Frodo C64 DosBox: DOSBOX Turbo FM7 :XM7 MAC: Mini vMac Mini vMac II Newton OS:einstein MSX MSX.emu MRP platform : mrpoid Telmac 1800 8-bit :Android Chip-8 Emulator Orao 8-bit:Orao Emulator Palm OS : PHEM StyleTap PC98 : NP2 J98 PC88:QUASI88 (thx angelhp) X68000:PX68K for Andorid ZX81:Zed Ex ZX Spectrum :Xpectroid ZX Spectrum Emulator

You neglected to mention that 3DS development began in 2009 and was released in 2011. I could not find any information online regarding when GPD XD development started but it was released in 2015. So there are multiple years in the difference of release times which is a long time in modern mobile processor technology. You are comparing hardware released at different times with an unfair bias towards the more recently released one. And you did not mention that 3DS has two independent screens while GPD only has one. You also neglected to mention any of the software or network support that Nintendo develops and provides for it’s own platform and gaming ecosystem. And you incorrectly stated that the 3DS “only supports their own platform game” which I assume you mean 3DS games. Nintendo has a well respected commercial emulator platform in the form of Virtual Console. So the 3DS supports Game Boy, Game Boy Color, Sega Game Gear and NES games. With SNES on the New 3DS. And most amazing of all, you completely failed to mention any of the opensource emulators available on a modified 3DS, including RetroArch! And lets not forget backwards compatibility with DS either, and all the emulators available via that method aswell.

Hardware alone is poor comparison of overall value since hardware is only the vehicle for good software. And the Nintendo 3DS is widely regarded as another very successful handheld gaming platform with highly rated 1st and 3rd party software. Nice and all that the GPD XD is for emulation and some Android store gaming, it has to rely on the investment and development of others to survive. Nintendo has to recoup all of it’s R&D costs for both hardware and software through sales of both kinds of products. It looks to me GPD only has to deal with hardware costs. Without companies like Nintendo innovating and influencing the market with their hardware and software, devices like the GPD XD which are clearly clones, arguably would not exist.

GPD will have a new product for the GPD WIN

This discussion should be in RetroArch Android. Maybe you can make your sales pitch for GPD there.


This is the latest product of GPD