You shouldn’t have to share any of your original PSD.
It’s not a matter of “have to”, just an honest question about if those resources are available to us. It seems they are not. Okay! That’s fine. I’m glad you shared your borders with the world, John, because they’re excellent. Thanks for making them.
As for the dirt, yes, it’s totally true to life. But that doesn’t mean I want to recreate that when I don’t have to. It’s like with shader-based CRT simulation, when people chase a mythical “perfect CRT” with faultless geometry that never physically existed. I think that’s fine too. It’s all about our personal preferences, and one of the things I love about RetroArch is its ability to be so many things to so many people.
Any more thoughts on a border repository of some sort? It would be great just to have it for easier general retrieval, but if it also made it easier for the average user to access such content, even better.